NoteCast 45
Comparing Immediate and Early Loading in Single Implants
In this episode we reviewed a systematic review published in the Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry (JPD) in 2018. The aim of the study was to compare the success and the bone loss around single implants under two treatment protocols, Immediate Load and Early Load, over a period of 1 to 3 years.
Key definitions and loading protocols
In the scientific sources of implantology, the timing of prosthesis delivery is defined in three broad categories (although their time windows are defined somewhat differently in different sources):
- Conventional (Delayed) Loading: a wait of about 3 months for osseointegration to be completed, followed by delivery of the prosthesis.
- Immediate Loading: delivery of the restoration (definitive or provisional) immediately after surgery; according to the definition in Misch's textbook (2020) this window extends up to 2 weeks, but this paper used a window of up to 72 hours.
- Early Loading: delivery of the prosthesis in the intermediate window; that is, after the Immediate period ends (after 72 hours or 2 weeks) and before the 3-month conventional period is completed.
Key findings and clinical notes
- Implant survival rate: at 1 to 3 years of follow-up, no statistically significant difference in implant survival was observed between the Immediate Load and Early Load methods, and with high torque during placement, both protocols give predictable and safe results.
- Marginal bone loss: the amount of bone loss around the implants was similar in both groups, and no significant difference between them was recorded.
- The importance of insertion torque and primary stability: according to the study by Ottoni et al., which is cited in the paper, reaching an initial torque of 32 Ncm plays a vital role in reducing treatment failure and ensuring successful osseointegration under immediate loading (even more important than bone quality or implant length). At torques of 20 or 45 Ncm, a higher failure rate than at 32 Ncm has been reported.
- Challenges of the first 30 days under immediate loading: some studies outside this review have shown that under immediate loading, bone loss occurs with greater intensity in the first 30 days. This may result from the early application of force, a difference in the course of bone remodeling, or the presence of a microgap at the implant–abutment junction with bacterial accumulation (in addition to factors such as implant design, surgical trauma and the surgeon's skill).
Clinical conclusion
In single-unit treatment, there is no difference between the Immediate Load and Early Load protocols in survival or in preservation of marginal bone over 1 to 3 years, provided the patient has been selected correctly and adequate primary stability is achieved at surgery.
The content of this page is intended for the educational use of dentists and dental students.